The Modern Homeowner’s Dilemma
Creating the perfect lawn has never been more exciting — or more confusing. Today’s Winnipeg homeowners are increasingly exploring artificial grass (also called synthetic turf, fake grass, or high-quality artificial grass) as a low-maintenance, year-round green option. At the same time, the timeless beauty and natural feel of real grass continue to be an essential part of the classic Prairie landscape.
With rising concerns about water usage, environmental impact, and ongoing maintenance costs, many homeowners are wondering which option offers the best balance of beauty, value, and sustainability.
In this guide, we’ll break down artificial grass vs real grass from the perspective of Winnipeg’s unique weather conditions, sustainability, lifestyle needs, and long-term investment. As landscape experts, we’re here to help you make a confident, informed choice for your yard.
Understanding the Differences
Artificial Grass (Synthetic Turf)
Modern synthetic grass is a far cry from the short plastic turf of the past. Today’s high quality synthetic grass uses:
- Polyethylene or polypropylene grass blades
- Infill, often sand or a sand/rubber mix, to support the blades and improve drainage
- A durable backing system that keeps the turf stable and secure
Artificial turf is ideal for outdoor areas where real grass struggles — shaded yards, pet runs, high-traffic areas, and play zones where homeowners want a clean, low-maintenance surface. Installing artificial grass offers an attractive, green, and maintenance-free look year-round.
Real Grass (Natural Sod)
A natural grass lawn works as a living system. Its root structure, combined with healthy soil, supports water absorption, carbon storage, and even helps produce oxygen. Popular choices in Winnipeg — such as Kentucky Bluegrass — grow well in our climate and offer that soft, cool, classic feel under your feet.
A natural lawn is ideal for homeowners who value:
- Natural cooling in hot weather
- A yard that contributes to air quality and supports local ecosystems
- That unmistakable, beautiful natural lawn texture and smell
Climate Considerations: Winnipeg’s Seasons and Their Impact
Winnipeg’s climate is anything but predictable. Between freeze-thaw cycles, dry summers, intense direct sunlight, and harsh winter snow loads, lawns must be built to withstand extremes.
Artificial Turf in Winnipeg Weather
Synthetic turf performs well in cold climates, but professional installation is key. Proper base preparation, drainage layers, and grading prevent issues like frost heave, rippling, or trapped meltwater. Snow can stay on the surface, but heavy drifts should be gently brushed — no metal shovels.
Because turf doesn’t absorb moisture, meltwater management is especially important. At North Coral Landscaping we ensure water can efficiently drain into the underlying base and surrounding area.
Real Grass in Winnipeg Weather
A healthy natural turf handles winter remarkably well. Roots go dormant and regrow each spring. However, poor drainage, shade, or foot traffic can lead to:
- Bare patches
- Ice damage
- Soil compaction
Professional soil prep, irrigation planning, and seasonal aeration will help your real lawn stay healthy year after year.
Maintenance: Which Is Easier Long-Term?
Artificial Grass Maintenance
Artificial grass offers simplicity. No lawn mower, no fertilizers, no pest control, and no weekly watering. Maintenance includes:
- Occasional brushing to lift flattened grass blades
- Rinsing to remove dust or pet waste (a mild detergent can be used)
- Infill top-ups over the years
- Light brushing for snow removal
Real Grass Maintenance
A real lawn requires regular care to stay healthy:
- Mowing weekly during peak season
- Thorough watering during hot days
- Fertilizing to replace lost nutrients
- Aeration to avoid compaction
- Weed control
- Reseeding or patch repair when needed
Effort vs Reward Comparison Table
| Factor | Artificial Grass | Real Grass |
| Watering | None | Regularly required |
| Fertilizing | No | Seasonal |
| Snow Removal | Light brushing | Standard shovelling |
| Longevity | 15–20 years | Indefinite with proper care |
Environmental Impact and Sustainability
The environmental benefits of grass — real or artificial — depend on how you look at them.
Artificial Grass
Pros
- Saves thousands of litres of water annually
- Reduces carbon emissions from lawn equipment
- No fertilizers or chemicals needed
Cons
- Made from plastic materials
- Limited recycling options for old turf
- Can warm up more on hot days
Real Grass
Pros
- Helps reduce air pollution by capturing dust and carbon dioxide
- Supports local ecosystems with soil organisms and insects
- Creates a cooling effect in hot weather
Cons
- Requires water and sometimes fertilizers
- Needs mowing, which can increase carbon emissions unless using electric mowers
North Coral Expert Insight:
For Winnipeg’s climate, eco-balance can be achieved through hybrid designs — mixing natural greenery with low-maintenance turf zones.
Cost Comparison: Upfront vs Lifetime Investment
Upfront Costs
- Artificial grass installation: $15–$25 per square foot
- Natural sod: $3–$5 per square foot
Artificial turf has a higher initial cost, largely due to base construction and professional installation.
Ongoing Maintenance Costs
- Artificial Turf: Very low
- Real Grass: Watering, mowing, fertilizers, aeration, weed control, and potential patch repair all add up over the years
These are rough estimates — contact North Coral for an accurate quote for your yard.
Safety, Comfort, and Family Use
Families, pets, and play areas all have different needs.
Artificial Turf
- Stays clean and mud-free
- Great for dogs (no holes or bare patches)
- Can warm up in hot weather, though high quality artificial grass helps reduce heat retention
- Non-toxic turf options are available through North Coral Landscaping
Real Grass
- Cooler on hot days
- Soft, natural feel
- Can get muddy or worn in high traffic areas
- Offers natural environmental benefits
Combining Both for a Premium Design
Many Winnipeg homeowners choose a hybrid landscape for the best of both worlds.
Examples include:
- Using synthetic turf in shaded or high-traffic zones
- Keeping natural grass in open sunny spaces for that natural feel
- Pairing turf with stone pathways and natural plantings
North Coral Expert Insight:
At North Coral Landscaping, we can design a custom blend of artificial turf, natural lawn, stonework, and garden beds to create a perfectly balanced outdoor space.
Choosing What’s Right for You
Both artificial and real grass have clear benefits — it all depends on your lifestyle, environmental priorities, and how you use your outdoor space. Whether you prefer the traditional charm of a real grass lawn or the convenience of a low maintenance artificial lawn, North Coral Landscaping can help you choose the right fit.
Whether you’re dreaming of a lush natural lawn or a modern, maintenance-free space, North Coral Landscaping will help design a yard that fits your lifestyle — beautifully.
FAQ
A: Typically 15–20 years, depending on use and quality.
A: Yes — just avoid metal shovels. Light brushing is all that’s needed.
A: Real grass supports ecosystems and absorbs CO₂, but requires water and fertilizers. It depends on your priorities.
A: Rinse periodically to remove dust; use a mild detergent for tougher spots.
A: Absolutely! Hybrid designs are becoming increasingly popular for Winnipeg properties.